Rent vs. buy calculator

Compare where you'd stand financially after renting versus buying for the same number of years. The calculator counts every major cost on both sides and shows the year when buying starts to pay off.

Buying
Of home value
Renting
Time

Buying comes out ahead by

$38,953

  • Buyer's net worth after selling$200,119
  • Renter's investments$161,165
  • Buying pulls ahead inYear 7
First-month cost to own$3,125.44
Cash to buy$52,000
Home value at the end$537,567
Loan balance at the end$305,194

If you'll stay at least 7 years, buying is likely the better deal with these assumptions.

How the rent vs. buy calculator works

The calculator follows both paths month by month for as long as you plan to stay. The buyer pays the down payment and closing costs upfront, then principal, interest, property tax, insurance, maintenance, and HOA dues each month. Home value grows at the rate you set. The renter pays rent and renters insurance, with rent rising once a year.

To compare fairly, the renter invests the cash the buyer spent upfront. Each month, whichever side has the lower housing cost invests the difference at your investment return. At the end, the buyer sells: their net worth is the home value minus selling costs and the remaining loan, plus anything they invested. The renter's net worth is their investment balance.

Worked example

Take a $400,000 home with 10% down at 6.5%, a 1.1% tax rate, $1,800 a year for insurance, and 1% a year for maintenance. The first month of owning costs about $3,125, compared with $2,400 in rent. The buyer spends $52,000 upfront, which the renter invests at 5% instead.

After 10 years, with 3% yearly growth in both home values and rent, the home is worth about $537,567 and the loan balance is about $305,194. After 6% selling costs, the buyer has about $200,119, while the renter's investments have grown to about $161,165. Buying comes out ahead by about $38,953, and it first pulls ahead in year 7.

Change "Years you'll stay" to 3 and the answer flips: the renter comes out ahead by about $22,370, because the buyer's closing and selling costs haven't been recovered yet.

Reading the result

Treat the result as a range, not a promise. Home prices, rents, and investment returns won't follow a straight line. Run a cautious case and an optimistic case, and if buying wins in both, you can be more confident. Also consider the things the numbers don't capture: the stability and control of owning, versus the flexibility and lower responsibility of renting.

Frequently asked questions

Is it better to rent or buy?

It depends mostly on how long you'll stay. Buying has big upfront and selling costs that take years to recover through equity and appreciation. Renting is usually cheaper for short stays, and buying usually wins the longer you stay. The calculator finds the year where buying pulls ahead for your numbers.

How does the calculator compare renting and buying fairly?

It assumes the renter invests the money a buyer would spend upfront, plus any month when renting costs less than owning. The buyer invests in months when owning is cheaper. At the end, it compares the buyer's home equity after selling costs, plus investments, with the renter's investments.

What costs of owning are included?

Principal and interest, property tax, homeowners insurance, maintenance, and HOA dues each month, plus closing costs when you buy and selling costs when you sell. Maintenance is often estimated at about 1% of the home's value per year.

Why does the break-even year matter so much?

If you're likely to move before the break-even year, renting will probably leave you with more money. If you'll stay well past it, buying probably comes out ahead. It's the single most useful number for this decision.

What assumptions matter most?

Home price growth, rent growth, and the return the renter earns on invested savings have the biggest effect over long periods. Try more cautious values, like 2% appreciation or a higher investment return, to see how sensitive the answer is.

Does this include tax benefits?

No. Most buyers now take the standard deduction, so mortgage interest and property tax deductions often don't change the result. If you itemize, buying looks somewhat better than shown.

Sources

Results are estimates for planning and education, not a loan offer or financial advice. Your lender's Loan Estimate shows your actual terms.

All mortgage and home buying calculators